Critical Care for
Companies®
Turnaround Step 2: How Do You Know That Your Business is in Trouble?
Why you should read this section
·
There are tools to determine if your business is in the
Zone of Insolvency
and it is important that you know this
·
You will learn a concept called
Fraudulent
Conveyance
and how this can land you in jail if you are not careful
Causes of Business Failure versus
Symptoms of Business Failure
In Turnaround step
1, you were exposed to a number of causes of business failure. In this
section, we will focus on symptoms. This will assist you in determining
the degree of trouble your business is in.
Symptoms of a sick or failing business include:
·
Cash flow difficulties such as frequent difficulties in making payroll
or vendors continually calling about getting paid
·
Low
morale of employees and higher then normal turnover
·
Nervous banker with possible threats of calling your loan
·
Flat
sales or worse, declining at a significant rate
·
Always fire fighting and problem solving
·
You
find you are continually in a crisis management mode
·
Perhaps a confused sense of direction or no consistent strategy for the
business
How
sick is your business….are you in the Zone of Insolvency?
First of all, what
is the Zone of Insolvency? While there is not a clear-cut test for
insolvency, a corporation or business can be said to be in the "zone" or
"vicinity" of insolvency if its liabilities exceed its assets (balance
sheet insolvency) or it is unable to pay its debts as they come due
(equitable insolvency).
It is time to dig
into the financial statements, specifically your most recent Balance
Sheet. Before you do, however, you must be very confident that your
financial statements are accurate. This can be one of the biggest
problems with distressed businesses. If the financial statements are not
accurate, then the remainder of the Critical Care for Companies™
Turnaround Program will be very difficult to pull off.
How do you know if your financial
statements are accurate?
Most failed
companies have non-existent or poor financial reporting systems. Your
company may lack accurate information in three critical areas: profits,
costs and cash position. Without good budgetary controls, you never know
how profitable you are or even if you are operating above or below your
break-even point. Without a good costing system, you won't understand
how key activities relate to your bottom-line profits. And without good
cash flow projections, you can never anticipate the next peak demand for
cash or how you will meet it. Businesses that operate without audited
statements are far more prone to financial distortions, whether
intentional or not. Your statements may be nothing more than erroneous
information. Now is the time to review your financial statements-perhaps
with the assistance of your accountant. Note: many accounts are very
good at preparing taxes but not good at financial analysis. This
is a critical area and I strongly urge to you seeking competent outside
assistance if you are financially challenged when it comes to
interpreting your business's financial statements.
When digging into
your financials, here are a few key areas to run a "reality check" to
see if you will need a more detailed audit of your books.
-
Have you
overestimated inventories?
-
How about
accounts receivable? Check the accuracy of the company's financial
statements (Balance Sheet in this case) as a starting point. How do
your financials compare with your Receivables Aging Report? Have your
overvalued receivables?
-
Do sales (on the
Income Statement) seem accurate?
-
What about
expenses, do they seem accurate?
-
Do sales (on the
Income Statement) seem accurate?
-
What about
expenses, do they seem accurate?
Remember, all you
are trying to do at this point in the analysis is get a degree of
confidence that your financials are accurate. If you even sense that
they are distorted, get a qualified accountant in ASAP to reconstruct
your financial statements!!
Liquidity
Ratios
Assuming that your
financials are accurate, you can now dig into a couple of simple ratios
to determine the liquidity of your business.
Liquidity ratios
measure the amount of cash available to cover both current and long-term
expenses. These ratios are especially important in keeping your business
alive. If you run out of cash and your business is struggling, then
chances are that the game will be over as it will be very difficult to
raise more cash for your struggling business.
Current Ratio
Current Assets
divided by Current Liabilities
The generally
accepted standard is a ratio of 2:1. This means that you have $2 of
assets for every $1 of liabilities. A very low ratio means you will be
having difficulty paying off your creditors and maintaining adequate
cash flow in your business. It also means you are probably in the Zone
of Insolvency and that is a very bad place to be!
Acid Test or Quick Ratio
The same as
current ratio except it eliminates inventory so that only cash and
accounts receivable are counted. If you want to be extra conservative
when you run this calculation, reduce your receivables by some
percentage (10-30% depending on your confidence in collecting them).
Cash+Accounts
Receivable divided by Current Liabilities
A safe margin
would be at least 1:1, or $1 of Cash & Accounts Receivable for every $1
of Current Liabilities.
Working Capital
Working capital is
the money you must have to operate your business on a daily basis-to pay
salaries and other bills.
Working
capital=current assets-current liabilities
Any one of the
previous calculations can give you more clarity into the liquidity of
your business. Remember, liquidity is like the gas in your car's tank.
When you are out of gas, everything stops!
Kauffman Business EKG
(this link will take you to the EKG analysis)
This is a free
financial benchmarking service provided by the Ewing Marion Kauffman
Foundation that is very impressive. I recommend you take a few minutes
and enter your data (now that you have your financial statements in
front of you) into their system.
The Kauffman
Business EKG provides a comprehensive assessment of your company’s
financial vital signs. This is what their website states about the
analysis:
"You will discover insights about your company’s financial well being
and how you compare to the “best of the class” in your industry. The
assessment requires only a few minutes and will give you ideas and
strategies for improving your company’s long-term financial health".
What are officers and directors
responsibilities while in the Zone of Insolvency and how does operating
in the Zone differ from business as usual?
There is perhaps
no other time when officers and directors are more concerned about
personal liability for their decisions on behalf of a business, than
when the business begins to experience financial problems. Officers and
directors are accustomed to evaluating the best interest of the
businesses' shareholders in their regular decision making process;
however, once a corporation becomes insolvent, officers and directors
must also consider the interests of creditors.
If you have
determined that your business is in the Zone of Insolvency and since I
am not an attorney, I would strongly recommend that you seek competent
legal council as this is very dangerous ground to be on. You can be
held personally liable for your business decisions. Of particular
concern is some thing called Fraudulent Conveyance of Assets.
What does Fraudulent Conveyance of
Assets mean?
The illegal
transfer of property to another party in order to defer, hinder or
defraud creditors. In order to be found guilty of fraudulent conveyance,
it must be proven that the accused's intention for transferring the
property was to put it out of reach of a known creditor. If you are in
the Zone of Insolvency you must be very careful in this area and,
as already stated, I would highly recommend you consult an attorney if
you are in the Zone. This can be a very tricky area and can land you in
jail!!
|